Perceiving that you perceive
Giovanni Kerkhof · 2026-11-01
What is unique, or seems to be unique, is that people can be conscious of that perceiving. That you can perceive that you perceive. I keep the hedge in deliberately, because I put it there myself: an animal perceives, but it is not perceived that it perceives. At least, that is how it looks. I cannot climb inside a dog's skull. But everything I can observe suggests the second layer — the perceiving of the perceiving — is ours.
And that second layer is not decoration; it is leverage. Because we alone are conscious of attention, we can also direct it. We know it — and because we know it, we can aim it. An animal, it seems, cannot. An animal cannot steer its attention; attention is pulled, attention is had. Something rustles and the head turns. There is awareness in there, there are neurological processes, but — so far as I can see — no ownership of the beam.
Follow that one step further and you arrive at thinking itself. An ape is not conscious of its thinking, yet it thinks; and without its consciousness it could not think even that much. What it seems to lack is the holding. "Animals are not able to be conscious about their thoughts" — nor conscious of their attention on those thoughts, and so they cannot keep their attention resting on a thought; that, it seems to me, is why they cannot think. To think — sustained, directed thinking — you must keep attention resting on a thought, and for that you must be aware of the attention and of the thought as a thought. An ape can use a stone as an instrument, but it cannot discover patterns. A human can hold the pattern still, turn it over, and ask where it comes from: next to the correlation, a human can find a causality. Recognizing patterns, applying them, what succeeds gets rewarded and simply carries on. That loop, run consciously, is perhaps how we outgrew what held every other animal in place.
So there is a ladder. An animal is not conscious of its consciousness. A human can be conscious of their consciousness. And a human can be conscious that the human is consciousness. That last rung is this whole chapter in one line: not that you can have awareness, but — as I once put it, asking whether the ape could ever attain it — you can, because you can be conscious; more than that, you are consciousness.
And none of this is reserved for the clever. There are people who cannot think but who can feel, and be aware of what they feel. An ape, it seems to me, cannot even do that. The feeler who knows they are feeling already has the whole thing.
Be honest about the proportions, though. Of everything the brain does, "some thoughts they are aware of—maybe one, two, three percent. The rest is all subconscious, processed and reacted on." A sliver. But the sliver is everything, because "we can have some awareness about the thoughts and that they are thoughts. And that's why we can re-process thoughts." Re-processing — taking a thought back up instead of merely being run by it — is where the freedom lives. Even a simple question is this sliver in action: questions are, in effect, manifested awareness. A question is awareness of a need, made visible.