Who Does the Attention?
Giovanni Kerkhof · 2026-10-02
So I ask the question underneath the faculty: does the attention happen, or do you do the attention? And if you do it, who then is doing it? When I look honestly, I cannot find the doer. It is not consciousness that does it. Consciousness is aware of the attending, but it is not the agent of the attending. The attending seems to sit lower down, in the machinery: it sits in the body. Attention is a bodily process with a bodily budget, and it is limited, while awareness, I keep circling back to this, has no limitation at all. A narrow beam inside a boundless light.
The narrowness shows up everywhere once you look for it. Divide the beam and consciousness itself thins: you can be with your attention, or divided in it, and divided you are simply less conscious. Park the beam in thinking and you vacate your own organism — when the awareness is with the thinking, it is not with the system, not with the life — the breath goes on unwitnessed. And even at full strength the beam captures almost nothing of what the machinery produces: "I have been thinking 100% and I might take one or two percent of these thoughts come to my attention." Two percent. When meditation seems to increase my thoughts, that is an illusion of the same arithmetic — do nothing but attend to thinking and it merely seems you think more. The subconscious flood was always there; attention only made a sliver of it visible.
Worse: the beam is not even mine to steer. My memories, my learning, my accumulated somethings — all those things determine where the attention points, which means that what I have and am not now has me under control. I know this from the inside. My addiction is innovating — is that my attention? Unbelievable. I see it happen: I am conscious of the jumping, I see those thoughts — a thinking with no borders, and always the compulsion: the new things must be written down, must not be forgotten. It can look like a quality, but it is an addiction, for the simple reason that I am not free in it. The test of whether attention is instrument or master is freedom, and by that test I fail more often than I pass.